CORRECTION: GOP Outraising, Outspending Democrats in Council Race

There's a wide financial chasm between the Republicans and Democrats running for Moorestown council, but both parties say it's not about the money.

CORRECTION: The joint committee report for the Newcomer-Sattinger-Hines team shows the candidates have raised a total of $7,245—$3,325 from contributions of $300 or less, and $3,920 from contributions exceeding $300—and includes an itemized list of several of their donors.

The 29-day pre-election report also indicates the candidates have spent $4,870 (as of Oct. 12), all of it on advertising, including with Patch.

Patch apologizes for the errors included in the prior version of this story. 


As of earlier this month, the Republican candidates for Moorestown council had out-fundraised their Democratic counterparts by almost 3 to 1 and outspent them by a 5-to-1 margin, according to campaign finance reports.

According to the 29-day pre-election report filed by the Republican committee, the GOP candidates—Phil Garwood, Victoria Napolitano and Pete Palko—had received $31,920 in contributions, plus an infusion of $6,736 from a previous campaign. They’d spent $23,316, primarily on advertising (including ads with Patch), promotional materials and consulting.

On the other side of the aisle, the Democratic candidates—Greg Newcomer, Brian Sattinger and Mark Hines—individually raised $6,775, according to reports they filed separately, with each candidate individually raising between $2,100-$2,400. A joint committee report filed by the Democrats showed they raised $7,245 collectively—for a total of $14,020 raised between all four reports—and spent $4,870, all of it on advertising. 

Democratic campaign manager Francine Cartwright said the candidates knew they’d be at a disadvantage financially speaking in such a heavily Republican town, so they focused their efforts elsewhere.

“That’s why we were busy trying to meet people, instead of it being a campaign about how many fliers we can get out or how many ads we can place online or in the newspaper,” she said. “Ours is a ground campaign.”

GOP campaign manager Steve Solomon also downplayed the significance of the numbers in determining the outcome of the election.

“It’s all about knocking (on doors),” he said. “We’re at over 4,000 knocks right now.”

He acknowledged the party’s cash flow is “nice” because of what it allows the campaign to do.

“It gives us billing recognition … flexibility. If we need something, we can go out and get it,” Solomon explained.

According to Solomon, the fundraising for this election, while impressive, hasn’t matched the amount of money the Gallo-Button-Testa ticket raised during the 2008 election.

“This is a fresh group of candidates, with really no record to run on,” Solomon said of this year’s Republican slate. “.”

To view the campaign finance reports, visit the New Jersey Election Law Enforcement Commission website, click on “View a Report,” and then “View a Candidate or Committee Report” and search for the candidates by name. To find the Democratic candidates' joint committee report, leave "Candidate Name" and "Committee Name" blank and search by location (Moorestown Township), Party Affilitation (Democrat), Election Type (General) and Year (2012). 

"Like" Moorestown Patch on Facebook to stay current on all the latest news and events.

Moorestown Republican October 27, 2012 at 11:42 AM
Awesome! This is great news, no wonder the Democrats have such a bad website and keep sending mail to hardcore Republicans like me..........
Concerned October 27, 2012 at 11:48 AM
Uh... Rob, I hope you are asking some hard questions of the Dems right about now. How did they afford hundreds of lawn signs, robocalls, their first mailer to THE WHOLE TOWN, a tent at Moorestown Day, balloons, ads in the Moorestown Sun, ads on the Patch, and ONLY spend $618??? This doesn't smell right. Who's paying for this campaign??? Too many missing numbers...... Math doesn't make any sense
Another voter October 27, 2012 at 12:15 PM
Yesterday was the third robocall we got from the democrats. The first two did not have a "paid for by..." in their call. Is that ok for these robocalls to go out without any tag of who paid for it? To answer the rep earlier, some of my friends are loyal solid republicans and they got these robocalls from democrats too. They sent these political pieces in the mail. "concerned" has a great point. Actually obvious one. We can easily account for three robocalls, all of these mailers, candy, spot at mtown day, and lawn signs ($400??) If it was donated, at least an "in kind donation" right? At the very least score this "sloppy" . What type of strategy does the democrat party in town have at this point? Is it a desperate one? Or is it just sloppy? I also hears the democrats were pushing candy at the Halloween parade? At least during the parade, the republican town council candidates didn't push themselves on us or our kids. They had their rally, we residents were able to go to the side of the street say hi to the candidates as we marched down main st, very friendly. Buy as mt Solomon said here in this article, I've heard too that the candidates and their team have knocked a lot of doors.
Paula G. October 27, 2012 at 12:17 PM
Donnerstag October 27, 2012 at 12:52 PM
Look folks, gonna have to be perfectly honest here. That last piece in the mail by the democrats is a low blow and yes they are now sounding desperate. The loose strategy of trying to paint a broad brush at this late hour is a poor choice. Especially since there is a plan and bids are out. This is an upsetting move by the democrats and trying to use anything again to see if it will stick. It appears more 11th tactics may backfire. Now, where's my pumpkin?
Pete October 27, 2012 at 02:18 PM
"Unlike the Republican committee report, the Democratic candidates’ report did not include an itemized list of donors." Hmmmmm. Wonder why..............
Rob Scott (Editor) October 27, 2012 at 03:05 PM
Readers, It has been brought to my attention that the original version of this story contained errors, because the Democratic candidates also filed a joint committee report in addition to their individual campaign finance reports. The joint report contained more information about how much they've raised, how much they've spent and how they spent it. I have amended the story to include the new information, and I apologize for the error. Searching ELEC can be tricky, but that's no excuse. Please make note of the corrections.
Donnerstag October 27, 2012 at 04:14 PM
Lets just say it the way it is, The republicans in moorestown have almost always done a good job with their campaigns. Who is doing polls?
another republican October 27, 2012 at 06:38 PM
Lawn signs? Hey RKO the Big 4-0 signs are spouting around town! have fun! Hey GNP, what happened with the all the green signs around town? did someone snatch them? well, I guess sandy will take them elsewhere soon, ugh!
TrueRepublican October 28, 2012 at 02:43 AM
Follow the money boys and girls... what does that tell you????
Leafblower October 28, 2012 at 12:58 PM
To GNP team: is your tailgate party with Mr Runyan still on? I was planning on coming after morning yard work. I'm guessing if the eagles are still on yous guys are on? Perhaps you'll update website? Hope this sandy doesn't come yet. Looks forwarding to see yous there!
Scared for my town October 28, 2012 at 01:33 PM
Wow, did anyone else see the Democrats money? Troy Singleton, Joe Roberts.... Someone made real nice with the Norcross machine.
another republican October 28, 2012 at 04:39 PM
Let's get it together.. 1) Is there still a town council meeting tomorrow night, esp since there is a state of emergency? 2) What are the latest polls for the upcoming election?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something